You're looking at the swatches and asking why I'm so disappointed as they all seem to perform fairly good, well they don't, in a way. If you're about to use a brush with the paler shades you can forget as you'll see nothing even after 3 minutes of packing colour on the lid! Fingers are the only tool that work for the first 4 shades in the palette, the remain 2 are the best out of them all working great with blending brushes and giving subtle colour to the crease giving a soft smoky look if you will. 

This palette has everything to be amazing it's just the formulas and pigmentation need improvement so we can get the most out of them without having the face full of eyeshadow after endless time of application. 

It's not a complete loss as I love the shades and still can make them work out with a bit more of time and patience. The price was merely 5€ or so but still I'm sad that it doesn't live up to what I was expecting from one of my favourite brands.